Pro-Growth Bias is reflected in the media by the stories and words chosen, which hint and often trumpet that economic, population, and consumption growth is good and essential. We're here to expose the bias and encourage more balanced and thoughtful journalism. Here you can vote, discuss, and even post stories exemplifying the bias.
Yesterday the Wall of Shame spotlighted particularly biased reporting by an Australian journalist, celebrating without question the economic, population and consumption growth of the state of New South Wales. Today I’m featuring the words of a community leader and policymaker in the city of Sanford, North Carolina.
The Sanford Herald recently ran this letter from Richard Hayes, a former county commissioner:
Sanford Must Summon Courage to Overcome Obstacles
The letter’s first paragraph contains all the usual suspects in growth mythology (I’ve underlined the culprits):
“The Sanford Herald has pinpointed various activities Sanford leaders have planned to ensure quality economic growth and to...
10 counties in south central Kansas, a university a think tank and a foundation share the spotlight today on the Wall of Shame. They are undertaking an effort called Blueprint for Regional Economic Growth, as reported by John Green in The Hutchinson News:
Economic Growth Group to Start
This story caught my eye, because the last thing a full planet needs is another “economic growth” group. But Wichita State University, several counties, the Kaufman Foundation and the Brookings Institution are apparently not up to speed. They’ve probably not read the latest Living Planet Report. They may have missed The Limits to...
The Gaston Gazette’s Eric Wildstein probably grew up like most of us, reading and hearing about the joys of population and economic growth. Even if he learned that human activity on the planet is disrupting the climate, extinguishing species and liquidating natural resources, that was never considered when his hometown or state celebrated topping some list of the fastest-growing. Somehow the growth of a city, county or state has nothing to do with the overshoot of global human population.
So I must resist the urge to label as clueless his recent Gazette story about population growth in North Carolina, and Gaston...
Yesterday The Arizona Republic occupied this space with a story about Arizona communities starting to reuse their wastewater in order to provide water “for growth.” Today we stick with the same newspaper, but a different reporter. In 5 Reasons to Panic About Arizona's Water, and 5 Reasons Not To, Shaun McKinnon updates us on a flurry of media reports about the dire state of fresh water supply in Arizona, but seems intent on avoiding any interpretation of crisis.
“Is Arizona really running out of water?
Yes. And no.
Here are five reasons why the drought should concern you and five more...
Today we honor on the Wall of Shame David Madrid, reporter for The Arizona Republic. He will have to share the honor, however, with Jason Battern, vice chairman of the Goodyear, Arizona Water Planning Commission. Mr. Battern caught our attention with this statement in Madrid’s story, West Valley Cities Eyeing Reclaimed Water Amid Drought, Population Growth:
"Without the water, there wouldn't be anybody out here. Water is what's supporting the population. Without it, there wouldn't be any growth."
I find this an interesting choice of words. If a water planning official in the arid American West mentions growth today, it should...